Obama '08

Why I don’t like living in New York

April 14, 2008 – 4:43 pm

So if you know me, you’ve probably heard me say more than once that I hate living in New York. If you don’t know me, I’ll say it again for your benefit. I hate. living. in. New York.

What?! But its the city of lights! Its the city that never sleeps! The theater! The culture! WHAT?!

I know. It’s hard to grasp. I’ll give you a moment before I continue.

Better? Ok, I’ll continue. For a long while, I kept bitching about living in New York without giving much thought as to why. It became a huge polarizing topic with certain friends of mine and none of them could get how I could ever hate New York. I got a lot of  “oh give it time, it will grow on you” speeches. A year and some change later, it has yet to grow on me and I still dislike it as much as I did before. Over the past week I’ve given a lot of thought to why some love this place and why I hate it so much. It comes down to this: values and Quality of Life.

Let me give you a bit of background. I lived in what could arguably be called a suburban area of Alaska for 12 or so years. Before that I lived in the suburbs of Miami and before that the suburbs of Clovis, New Mexico. Suffice to say I am a suburban girl. I like trees, I like being able to hop in the car and go somewhere, I like being able to walk/bike around with not a lot of worry that some jerkbag cab driver is going to hit me. I also like having a good amount of space in my residence and I like having grass. I like waking up without a lot of noise going on outside me. I value the majority of the things I just listed immensely. I don’t have the things I value so my Quality of Life is low and I’m pretty unhappy with my living situation.

Many of the people who don’t understand why I don’t like living here don’t put a lot of value into those things, yet they enjoy the hustle and bustle of the city. They value the bright lights, the plays, the food options, the “culture.” Thus their Quality of Life in New York is fairly good and they’re relatively happy.

So that’s pretty much that. If you’re a New Yorker reading this and you’re just appalled at the idea that anyone could dislike living here, think about what things make you happy here and then try to understand that those things don’t necessarily make others happy too.



  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Ginger Makela
    Being in NY makes me feel very claustrophobic!
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Clare Dibble
    If you really don't like New York, why don't you move?
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Erica Baker
    @Clare Believe me, I'm trying. :)
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Adam Lasnik
    'slike how I feel about SF. Great to visit, crappy to live in.
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Cassidy
    Good to hear someone's critical perspective who actually lives there. To NJ people, NY is practically Mecca. ...via AlertThingy
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Charlie Anzman
    Left 13 years ago ... never looked back
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Liz Burr
    I'm glad I could comment here on FF cuz your blog comments were disabled :( Anyhoo, I came by to say GO NEW MEXICO! I forgot you knew about Clovis, and other middle of nowhere towns in New Mexico. My grandma has always lived in NM or TX and *always* talks about how much she needs her SPACE and could never live in a city. I agree, but for now while I am childless and husbandless, the city will do. I couldn't even own a dog in the city, and I love animals! Suburbia for me, when I get a family.
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm TheJennTaFur
    I do understand where you are coming from having grown up in suburbia. For me as a native of Washington, DC who frequented NYC growing up, I knew what I was getting myself into when I moved there. You have to have balance to live there. It is not for everyone. I live in the city so I know I am spoiled to a certain extent with being able to walk to certain places such as my grocery and other shopping. And, delivery really has spoiled me!
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Erica Baker
    @calinative I fixed my comments, sorry about that and thanks for the heads up! I am childless and husbandless and I still need my space. Cities are fun for living close to but not living in.
  • December 31, 1969 at 7:33 pm Anthony Farrior
    Philadelphia isn't any better but as @Jennifer pointed out, the city spoils you and you don't really notice it until your in the middle of nowhere with the nearest "store" being a gas station 10 min away...

Add a comment on FriendFeed